About this property

Featuring an indoor pool and hot tub, Open Hearth Lodge is located in Door County’s Sister Bay. The town centre and access to Lake Michigan are 3 minutes’ drive away. Free WiFi access is available. Cable TV is provided in every air-conditioned room at Open Hearth Lodge. There is also a refrigerator and work desk. Featuring a shower, private bathrooms also come with a bath or shower and a hairdryer. Outdoor BBQ facilities and a fire pit are featured at Sister Bay Open Hearth Lodge. Pet friendly rooms are available in select rooms upon request. Other facilities offered at the property include access to hiking and biking trails and a children’s playground. The property offers free parking. Bay Ridge Golf Course is located across the street from this hotel. Peninsula State Park is 10 minutes’ drive away.

Couples particularly like the location — they rated it 9.5 for a two-person trip.

Distance in property description is calculated using © OpenStreetMap

Property highlights

Perfect for a 3-night stay!

  • Top location: Highly rated by recent guests (9.6)

  • Want a great night's sleep? This hotel was highly rated for its very comfy beds.

  • Top pick by families with children

Breakfast info

Continental

  • Free private parking available at the hotel


 ! 

Please select one or more options you want to book

Availability

We have no availability here between Sat 11 Oct 2025 and Tue 14 Oct 2025

Select different dates to see more availability

Checking for other dates
Room type
Number of guests
Price
Not available on our site for your dates
1 extra-large double bed
Not available on our site for your dates
1 sofa bed
and
2 large double beds
Not available on our site for your dates
1 extra-large double bed
Not available on our site for your dates
2 large double beds
Not available on our site for your dates
1 extra-large double bed
and
1 sofa bed
Not available on our site for your dates
1 extra-large double bed
Not available on our site for your dates
Bedroom
1 extra-large double bed
Living room
1 sofa bed
Not available on our site for your dates
Bedroom 1
1 extra-large double bed
Bedroom 2
1 extra-large double bed
Living room
1 sofa bed
Not available on our site for your dates
1 extra-large double bed
and
1 sofa bed
Not available on our site for your dates
1 sofa bed
and
2 large double beds
Not available on our site for your dates
1 single bed
and
1 sofa bed
Not available on our site for your dates
Bedroom
1 extra-large double bed
Living room
1 sofa bed
Not available on our site for your dates
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Something went wrong. Please try again later.
Limited supply in Sister Bay for your dates: 4 two-star hotels like this are already unavailable on our site

Guest reviews

Categories:

Staff
Facilities
Cleanliness
Comfort
Value for money
Location
Free WiFi

Select topics to read reviews:

Guests who stayed here loved

  • Denise
    United States United States
    It is always friendly and get a warm welcome. Love this it's our favorite place to stay
  • Cheryl
    United States United States
    We liked the location of the lodge. A little off the area of main activity but close enough to get there easily. The lodge was very cozy with the beautiful fire pit area and the seating inside around the fireplace. We loved boxing in the gym!
  • Swetha
    United States United States
    Clean and comfortable rooms. The property had a nice exercise area for dogs. The owner was very polite and accommodating!
  • Loretta
    United States United States
    The staff was excellent. The owner was exceptionally helpful and very knowledgeable.
  • Danielle
    United States United States
    Owner was very friendly, check in and out process very smooth. Rooms were clean comfortable and updated. Free breakfast in the morning exceeded expectations. Will definitely be back.
  • Ron/karolyn
    United States United States
    Breakfast area had beautiful view of the property with a well balanced food attraction. We appreciated the location of the resort because of the many things we were able to see.
  • Michael
    United States United States
    We loved the property! It was so relaxing and the staff was very friendly. We enjoyed the back yard of the property the most. The fire pits were our favorite. We will definitely stay here again!!
  • Francis
    United States United States
    this is a beautiful property with friendly staff that go out of their way to make everyone feel welcome. It is a great place to stay!
  • Lynda
    United States United States
    We thought the coffee and food were good for breakfast. There was something everyone in our family liked. The lodge was next to bike path. Excellent for dog walking. Staff was friendly and helpful.
  • Shannon
    United States United States
    Exceptionally clean everywhere you looked. Super friendly owner. Loved the fire pits and comfy chairs to relax outside

Hotel surroundings

House rules

Open Hearth Lodge takes special requests - add in the next step!
Check-in
From 15:00 to 22:00
Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in
Check-out
Until 11:00
Cancellation/ prepayment
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to accommodation type. Please check what conditions may apply to each option when making your selection.
Children and beds

Child policies

Children of any age are welcome.

Children 13 years and above will be charged as adults at this property.

To see correct prices and occupancy information, please add the number of children in your group and their ages to your search.

Cot and extra bed policies

0 - 1 year
Extra bed upon request
Free
Cot upon request
US$5 per child, per night
2 - 11 years
Extra bed upon request
Free
12+ years
Extra bed upon request
US$10 per person, per night

Prices for cots and extra beds are not included in the total price, and will have to be paid for separately during your stay.

The number of extra beds and cots allowed is dependent on the option you choose. Please check your selected option for more information.

All cots and extra beds are subject to availability.

No age restriction
There is no age requirement for check-in
Pets
Pets are allowed on request. Charges may be applicable.
Cards accepted at this hotel
American ExpressVisaMastercardDiscover

The fine print

Need-to-know information for guests at this property

Pet friendly rooms are available in select rooms upon request.

The property offers cribs for a fee of USD 5 per stay.

Please contact property if arriving after 22:00 for check-in procedure.

Guests are required to show a photo identification and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.

In response to Coronavirus (COVID-19), additional safety and sanitation measures are in effect at this property.

Food & beverage services at this property may be limited or unavailable due to Coronavirus (COVID-19).

Due to Coronavirus (COVID-19), this property is taking steps to help protect the safety of guests and staff. Certain services and amenities may be reduced or unavailable as a result.